Tax Alert -Federal Court delivers a Division 7A win for taxpayers in Bendel Case decision

Lowe Lippmann Chartered Accountants

Federal Court delivers a Division 7A win for taxpayers in Bendel Case decision


Last week the Full Federal Court handed down a unanimous decision that an unpaid present entitlement (or UPE) owed by a discretionary trust to a corporate beneficiary is not a “loan” for Division 7A purposes, which is a set of anti-avoidance provisions that could deem such a loan to be a deemed dividend.


This decision focuses on arrangements that will be familiar and common for many private groups across Australia that use discretionary trusts.


A brief history of the Bendel Case


The Bendel case involves two taxpayers, an individual and a private company, and both were beneficiaries of a discretionary trust. The individual was the director of both the corporate trustee of the discretionary trust and the corporate beneficiary.


For various income years, the trustee of the discretionary trust resolved to distribute income to the corporate beneficiary. The corporate beneficiary did not call for (or demand) payment of those entitlements. This is an unpaid present entitlement or UPE. This is a very common arrangement within private groups in Australia.


Since 2010, the Commissioner of Taxation has applied Division 7A on the basis that if a UPE owing by a discretionary trust to a corporate beneficiary is left unpaid, it could be a “financial accommodation” from the company to the trust and therefore be treated as a “loan”.


This loan is then deemed to be a dividend from the corporate beneficiary to the discretionary trust for the purposes of Division 7A.

In the Bendel case, the Commissioner decided that a deemed dividend would be included in the discretionary trust’s net income and assessed the taxpayers on their respective shares of that deemed dividend.


The taxpayers appealed to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT), which found for the taxpayers. Then the Commissioner appealed to AAT decision the Full Federal Court.


After waiting over a year, last week the Full Federal Court handed down a unanimous decision that a UPE owed by a discretionary trust to a corporate beneficiary is not a “loan” for Division 7A purposes.


Why is a UPE not treated as a “loan” now?


Broadly, a UPE arises where a trustee of a trust makes a beneficiary presently entitled to trust income, but the beneficiary does not receive payment for the entitlement.


The Full Federal Court’s decision clarified that for an arrangement to constitute a “loan,” there must be an obligation to repay an amount, rather than merely an obligation to pay an amount.


This critical finding distinguishes a UPE from a traditional loan, by reinforcing that a UPE does not inherently create a repayment obligation.


Beware Subdivision EA is still in play


While the decision provides a new interpretation regarding UPEs for Division 7A loan purposes, this decision does not change the potential for exposure to Subdivision EA.


Subdivision EA is a rule within Division 7A, which can be triggered if a trust makes a UPE to corporate beneficiary, and then the trust makes a payment or loan (for example) to the shareholders (or associates) of the corporate beneficiary.


Therefore we need to continue to monitor compliance with Subdivision EA, as it can still apply to deem the UPE to be a deemed dividend in certain circumstances.


What can the Commissioner do next?


While this decision represents a significant change in the interpretation of the Division 7A rules, it is unlikely to be the final word on the matter.


The Commissioner can still seek leave to appeal the Bendel decision to the High Court.


Another possibility for the Commissioner if he does not seek an appeal, is to approach the government to consider making amendments to the tax legislation and/or the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) guidance or administrative practices currently in place.



This decision is also likely to empower the accounting and taxation sector to continue to lobby the government to consider a broader review of the Division 7A rules, which we all agree is long overdue.


It is also worth noting that arrangements involving UPEs are still at risk of the ATO seeking to apply other taxation provisions such as Section 100A, which is an anti-avoidance provision that applies when a beneficiary’s entitlement to trust income results from a “reimbursement agreement”.  Broadly, this is an arrangement where a beneficiary becomes presently entitled to trust income, and someone (other than the beneficiary) receives a ‘benefit’ in relation to the arrangement with one of the parties having the intent of reducing tax. If a company’s entitlement to income remains unpaid by the trust indefinitely with no commercial arrangements to address it, Section 100A could well be an issue.


What can we do now?


Unfortunately, there is an element of having to “wait and see” what the Commissioner does next. However, there are some actions we can take in preparation for what developments come next.


If a taxpayer has been subject to ATO review or audit based on the previous interpretation of UPEs as loans and been forced to pay penalties, it would be relevant to consider the process for lodging an objection or seeking an amendment to their previous tax assessments.  This could potentially lead to the remission of primary tax, interest, and penalties.


It may also be relevant for any taxpayers currently being audited in this regard to discuss this new decision with their ATO audit case manager.


We will continue to stay updated on any new guidance or administrative practices issued by the ATO in response to the Full Federal Court's decision, as the ATO may provide further clarification or updates on how they may change their interpretation of UPEs going forward.



Please do not hesitate to contact your Lowe Lippmann Relationship Partner if you wish to discuss any of these matters further.

Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation


November 4, 2026
ATO to continue accepting credit cards until 30 June 2027, but the clock it still ticking Last month, in our Practice Update for October 2026 ( see here ), we noted the Australian Tax Office ( ATO ) announced it will stop accepting credit cards as a payment method after 30 November 2026, following the Reserve Bank of Australia’s ( RBA ) ban on card surcharges from 1 October 2026. The ATO has since confirmed that it will continue to accept credit card payments for tax obligations until 30 June 2027 . After 30 June 2027, taxpayers who wish to continue using a credit card to meet their tax obligations may continue to use third-party payment providers as outlined at www.ato.gov.au/howtopay What do these change mean for you? The extension does not cancel the planned withdrawal of direct credit card payments. From 1 July 2027, you will need to use another method to pay the ATO directly. Available alternatives include: Debit card BPAY Bank transfer Direct debit Payment at Australia Post (where available) International money transfer services (where applicable) Some third-party payment providers may continue to offer ways to pay tax using a credit card after the deadline. However, these services may charge additional fees and take longer to process payments. Check the total cost, processing time and payment conditions before relying on one. Why does your payment method matter? Credit cards can help bridge short-term cash-flow gaps, but the convenience comes at a cost. Interest, annual fees and other charges can erode the benefit, particularly if you regularly carry a balance. There is also a risk that a payment will not be processed in time, potentially leaving you with an overdue tax liability and additional interest. Switching to BPAY, bank transfer or direct debit may provide a simpler and more predictable way to manage tax payments. The right option will depend on your circumstances, including when funds are available in your business account and whether you need to retain flexibility over payment dates. Pay particular attention if you have an existing ATO payment plan linked to a credit card. The ATO has been contacting affected taxpayers, but you should check your own arrangements rather than assume they will continue unchanged. Confirm how future instalments will be paid and allow enough time to update the payment method before the deadline. What should you do now? Use the extended timeframe to prepare rather than leaving the change until the last minute. Review your current arrangements. Check whether you use a credit card for one-off tax payments, regular instalments or an ATO payment plan. Choose an alternative. Consider which payment method best suits your cash-flow cycle, taking account of fees and processing times. Update recurring payments early. Make sure any new arrangements are in place well before 30 June 2027 and check that payments are processed successfully. Review your cash flow. If you rely on the credit card interest-free period to manage tax liabilities, consider whether you need to set aside funds earlier or adjust your payment planning. Seek advice if needed. If tax payments are putting pressure on your cash flow, speak with us early so we can help you review your position and consider practical ways to manage upcoming liabilities. The extension to 30 June 2027 gives businesses more time to adjust, but it should not be mistaken for a permanent reprieve. Planning ahead can help you avoid unnecessary fees, missed payments and last-minute disruption when the ATO’s direct credit card facility closes.
October 7, 2026
ATO to stop accepting credit cards as payment method after 30 November 2026 The Australian Tax Office ( ATO ) has announced it will stop accepting credit cards as a payment method after 30 November 2026. The move follows after the Reserve Bank of Australia’s ( RBA ) Review of Merchant Card Payment Costs and Surcharging, where the RBA concluded that “it is in the public interest” to scrap surcharging for all designated card networks from 1 October 2026 (including EFTPOS, Mastercard, and Visa). It said that as a government agency, the ATO has decided it would not be appropriate for the cost of credit card merchant fees to be transferred to the community. The ATO recognises that some taxpayers currently rely on credit card payments to manage their tax payments and understands this change may require some adjustments. The ATO is writing directly to those who currently have a payment plan linked to a credit card to explain the changes and outlining the steps they need to take. There are alternative payment options available for taxpayers, including direct deposit, direct debit from a debit card, direct debit from an Australian cheque or savings account, Government EasyPay, in person at Australia Post, by mail, or international money remitter. The ATO said it is committed to helping taxpayers transition to alternative payment methods and will continue to support those experiencing financial hardship or other circumstances that make it difficult to meet their obligations. Alternative payment options for taxpayers are outlined at www.ato.gov.au/howtopay Taxpayers who need extra support are encouraged to visit www.ato.gov.au/supporttolodgeandpay , contact the ATO on 13 11 42 during business hours or speak with their registered tax professional.
September 4, 2026
Yesterday, Treasurer Jim Chalmers released draft legislation to implement the key components of the 30% minimum trust tax on discretionary trusts announced in the Federal Budget during May 2026.
More Posts